[{"_1":2,"_1641":-5,"_1642":-5},"loaderData",{"_3":4,"_11":12},"root",{"_5":6,"_7":6,"_8":9,"_10":9},"isProd",true,"enableStats","domain","lunaticoin.blog","siteHost","routes/$",{"_13":14,"_1494":1495},"json",{"_15":16,"_17":18,"_19":20,"_21":-5,"_22":-5,"_23":24,"_25":-5,"_26":27,"_591":6,"_37":592,"_603":604,"_605":606,"_1478":1479,"_1480":24,"_10":1481,"_1482":1481,"_1483":1484,"_1489":1490},"prefersLanguages",[],"viewTerm","activity","panelParam","activity/citations","openComment","accountUid","isInspect",false,"inspectTab","document",{"_28":29,"_566":461,"_567":568,"_569":570,"_572":573,"_574":575,"_576":577,"_578":579,"_582":583,"_584":40,"_585":586,"_589":590},"content",[30,49,56,73,80,103,117,171,193,223,230,237,244,251,258,294,301,308,315,322,329,336,343,363,370,377,388,394,401,408,415,422,428,434,498,505,512,524,538,545,559],{"_31":32,"_33":34},"children",[],"block",{"_35":36,"_37":38,"_39":40,"_41":42,"_43":44,"_45":46,"_47":48},"type","Paragraph","id","ls-EZDlV","revision","bafyreidqzzuf6mz5nmbbkjoviq6uaptf7n4g774eyywjaj2qhk6l2sdn5q","attributes",{},"annotations",[],"text","Dr. Alan Kay explains when \"object-oriented\" was first used and what it means.","link","",{"_31":50,"_33":51},[],{"_35":36,"_37":52,"_39":40,"_41":53,"_43":54,"_45":55,"_47":48},"twz-DvrW",{},[],"[] (Meaning of \"Object-Oriented Programming\" According to Dr. Alan Kay (meaning of OOP objectoriented definition term notion meaning explanation what is)), document, page 721691",{"_31":57,"_33":58},[],{"_35":36,"_37":59,"_39":40,"_41":60,"_43":61,"_45":72,"_47":48},"QSMkAOKj",{},[62],{"_35":63,"_64":65,"_67":68,"_41":70,"_47":71},"Link","starts",[66],0,"ends",[69],50,{},"https://www.purl.org/stefan_ram/pub/doc_kay_oop_en","https://www.purl.org/stefan_ram/pub/doc_kay_oop_en (permalink) is the canonical URI of this page.",{"_31":74,"_33":75},[],{"_35":36,"_37":76,"_39":40,"_41":77,"_43":78,"_45":79,"_47":48},"dPARTDlI",{},[],"Stefan Ram",{"_31":81,"_33":95},[82],{"_31":83,"_33":84},[],{"_35":36,"_37":85,"_39":40,"_41":86,"_43":87,"_45":94,"_47":48},"2My9CrTF",{},[88],{"_35":63,"_64":89,"_67":91,"_41":93,"_47":71},[90],53,[92],103,{},"(To link to this page, please use the canonical URI \"https://www.purl.org/stefan_ram/pub/doc_kay_oop_en\" only, because any other URI is valid only temporarily.)",{"_35":96,"_37":97,"_39":40,"_41":98,"_43":101,"_45":102,"_47":48},"Heading","Mq5W0qnm",{"_99":100},"childrenType","Group",[],"Dr. Alan Kay on the Meaning of “Object-Oriented Programming”",{"_31":104,"_33":112},[105],{"_31":106,"_33":107},[],{"_35":36,"_37":108,"_39":40,"_41":109,"_43":110,"_45":111,"_47":48},"sXghFk1O",{},[],"Dr. Alan Kay was so kind as to answer my questions about the term “object-oriented programming”.",{"_35":96,"_37":113,"_39":40,"_41":114,"_43":115,"_45":116,"_47":48},"nG8z5BhN",{"_99":100},[],"E-Mail of 2003-07-23",{"_31":118,"_33":166},[119,138,145,152,159],{"_31":120,"_33":121},[],{"_35":36,"_37":122,"_39":40,"_41":123,"_43":124,"_45":137,"_47":48},"8crspDMx",{},[125],{"_35":126,"_64":127,"_67":131,"_41":136,"_47":48},"Bold",[66,128,129,130],38,75,112,[132,133,134,135],5,41,80,120,{},"Date: Wed, 23 Jul 2003 09:33:31 -0800\nTo: Stefan Ram [removed for privacy]\nFrom: Alan Kay [removed for privacy]\nSubject: Re: Clarification of \"object-oriented\"",{"_31":139,"_33":140},[],{"_35":36,"_37":141,"_39":40,"_41":142,"_43":143,"_45":144,"_47":48},"MUvYIVRA",{},[],"[some header lines removed for privacy]",{"_31":146,"_33":147},[],{"_35":36,"_37":148,"_39":40,"_41":149,"_43":150,"_45":151,"_47":48},"HumG1iZL",{},[],"Content-Type: text/plain; charset=\"us-ascii\" ; format=\"flowed\"\nContent-Length: 4965\nLines: 117",{"_31":153,"_33":154},[],{"_35":36,"_37":155,"_39":40,"_41":156,"_43":157,"_45":158,"_47":48},"NzQYnOd-",{},[],"Hi Stefan --",{"_31":160,"_33":161},[],{"_35":36,"_37":162,"_39":40,"_41":163,"_43":164,"_45":165,"_47":48},"ddVKVxzu",{},[],"Sorry for the delay but I was on vacation.",{"_35":96,"_37":167,"_39":40,"_41":168,"_43":169,"_45":170,"_47":48},"KX-LJGO9",{"_99":100},[],"Clarification of \"object-oriented\" [E-Mail]",{"_31":172,"_33":187},[173,180],{"_31":174,"_33":175},[],{"_35":36,"_37":176,"_39":40,"_41":177,"_43":178,"_45":179,"_47":48},"hBxHwkqS",{},[],"Dear Dr. Kay,",{"_31":181,"_33":182},[],{"_35":36,"_37":183,"_39":40,"_41":184,"_43":185,"_45":186,"_47":48},"vYgKL4gU",{},[],"I would like to have some authoritative word on the term\n\"object-oriented programming\" for my tutorial page on the\nsubject. The only two sources I consider to be \"authoritative\"\nare the International Standards Organization, which defines\n\"object-oriented\" in \"ISO/IEC 2382-15\", and you, because,\nas they say, you have coined that term.",{"_35":36,"_37":188,"_39":40,"_41":189,"_43":191,"_45":192,"_47":48},"vnFM-lPA",{"_99":190},"Blockquote",[],"At 6:27 PM +0200 7/17/03, Stefan Ram wrote:",{"_31":194,"_33":218},[195,202,209],{"_31":196,"_33":197},[],{"_35":36,"_37":198,"_39":40,"_41":199,"_43":200,"_45":201,"_47":48},"Lz8ZCjXg",{},[],"Unfortunately, it is difficult to find a web page or source\nwith your definition or description of that term. There are\nseveral reports about what you might have said in this regard\n(like \"inheritance, polymorphism and encapsulation\"), but\nthese are not first-hand sources. I am also aware that later\nyou put more emphasis on \"messaging\" - but I still would like\nto know about \"object oriented\".",{"_31":203,"_33":204},[],{"_35":36,"_37":205,"_39":40,"_41":206,"_43":207,"_45":208,"_47":48},"oNpoa4V8",{},[],"For the records, my tutorial page, and further distribution\nand publication could you please explain:",{"_31":210,"_33":211},[],{"_35":212,"_37":213,"_39":40,"_41":214,"_43":216,"_45":217,"_47":48},"Code","KA_g8p43",{"_215":48},"language",[],"When and where was the term \"object-oriented\" used first? \n",{"_35":36,"_37":219,"_39":40,"_41":220,"_43":221,"_45":222,"_47":48},"IqPgafZs",{"_99":190},[],"I'm pretty sure I did.",{"_31":224,"_33":225},[],{"_35":36,"_37":226,"_39":40,"_41":227,"_43":228,"_45":229,"_47":48},"UaMGhpwm",{},[],"At Utah sometime after Nov 66 when, influenced by Sketchpad, Simula,",{"_31":231,"_33":232},[],{"_35":36,"_37":233,"_39":40,"_41":234,"_43":235,"_45":236,"_47":48},"Jlz8t4il",{},[],"the design for the ARPAnet, the Burroughs B5000, and my background in",{"_31":238,"_33":239},[],{"_35":36,"_37":240,"_39":40,"_41":241,"_43":242,"_45":243,"_47":48},"XRBvwnAx",{},[],"Biology and Mathematics, I thought of an architecture for",{"_31":245,"_33":246},[],{"_35":36,"_37":247,"_39":40,"_41":248,"_43":249,"_45":250,"_47":48},"auZRPDkT",{},[],"programming. It was probably in 1967 when someone asked me what I was",{"_31":252,"_33":253},[],{"_35":36,"_37":254,"_39":40,"_41":255,"_43":256,"_45":257,"_47":48},"FcDoSe6l",{},[],"doing, and I said: \"It's object-oriented programming\".",{"_31":259,"_33":288},[260,267,274,281],{"_31":261,"_33":262},[],{"_35":36,"_37":263,"_39":40,"_41":264,"_43":265,"_45":266,"_47":48},"nA-hHrYL",{},[],"I thought of objects being like biological cells and/or individual\ncomputers on a network, only able to communicate with messages (so\nmessaging came at the very beginning -- it took a while to see how to\ndo messaging in a programming language efficiently enough to be\nuseful).",{"_31":268,"_33":269},[],{"_35":36,"_37":270,"_39":40,"_41":271,"_43":272,"_45":273,"_47":48},"gE7ZEs88",{},[],"I wanted to get rid of data. The B5000 almost did this via its\nalmost unbelievable HW architecture. I realized that the\ncell/whole-computer metaphor would get rid of data, and that \"<-\"\nwould be just another message token (it took me quite a while to\nthink this out because I really thought of all these symbols as names\nfor functions and procedures.",{"_31":275,"_33":276},[],{"_35":36,"_37":277,"_39":40,"_41":278,"_43":279,"_45":280,"_47":48},"f-hU6Hj_",{},[],"My math background made me realize that each object could have\nseveral algebras associated with it, and there could be families of\nthese, and that these would be very very useful. The term\n\"polymorphism\" was imposed much later (I think by Peter Wegner) and\nit isn't quite valid, since it really comes from the nomenclature of\nfunctions, and I wanted quite a bit more than functions. I made up a\nterm \"genericity\" for dealing with generic behaviors in a\nquasi-algebraic form.",{"_31":282,"_33":283},[],{"_35":36,"_37":284,"_39":40,"_41":285,"_43":286,"_45":287,"_47":48},"QszOm2Np",{},[],"I didn't like the way Simula I or Simula 67 did inheritance\n(though I thought Nygaard and Dahl were just tremendous thinkers and\ndesigners). So I decided to leave out inheritance as a built-in\nfeature until I understood it better.",{"_35":36,"_37":289,"_39":40,"_41":290,"_43":292,"_45":293,"_47":48},"UBb1RKzJ",{"_99":291},"Unordered",[],"The original conception of it had the following parts.",{"_31":295,"_33":296},[],{"_35":36,"_37":297,"_39":40,"_41":298,"_43":299,"_45":300,"_47":48},"pqww0ALR",{},[],"My original experiments with this architecture were done using a model I adapted from van Wijngaarten's and Wirth's \"Generalization of Algol\" and Wirth's Euler. Both of these were rather LISP-like but with a more conventional readable syntax. I didn't understand the monster LISP idea of tangible metalanguage then, but got kind of close with ideas about extensible languages draw from various sources, including Irons' IMP.",{"_31":302,"_33":303},[],{"_35":36,"_37":304,"_39":40,"_41":305,"_43":306,"_45":307,"_47":48},"y9Lu6YMM",{},[],"The second phase of this was to finally understand LISP and then using this understanding to make much nicer and smaller and more powerful and more late bound understructures. Dave Fisher's thesis was done in \"McCarthy\" style and his ideas about extensible control structures were very helpful. Another big influence at this time was Carl Hewitt's PLANNER (which has never gotten the recognition it deserves, given how well and how earlier it was able to anticipate Prolog).",{"_31":309,"_33":310},[],{"_35":36,"_37":311,"_39":40,"_41":312,"_43":313,"_45":314,"_47":48},"Plqsu1cy",{},[],"The original Smalltalk at Xerox PARC came out of the above. The subsequent Smalltalk's are complained about in the end of the History chapter: they backslid towards Simula and did not replace the extension mechanisms with safer ones that were anywhere near as useful.",{"_31":316,"_33":317},[],{"_35":212,"_37":318,"_39":40,"_41":319,"_43":320,"_45":321,"_47":48},"i1wT2Wnl",{"_215":48},[],"What does \"object-oriented [programming]\" mean to you? \n(No tutorial-like introduction is needed, just a short \nexplanation [like \"programming with inheritance, \npolymorphism and encapsulation\"] in terms of other concepts \nfor a reader familiar with them, if possible. Also, it is \nnot neccessary to explain \"object\", because I already have \nsources with your explanation of \"object\" from \n\"Early History of Smalltalk\".) ",{"_31":323,"_33":324},[],{"_35":36,"_37":325,"_39":40,"_41":326,"_43":327,"_45":328,"_47":48},"s3GZATSp",{},[],"(I'm not against types, but I don't know of any type systems that aren't a complete pain, so I still like dynamic typing.)",{"_31":330,"_33":331},[],{"_35":36,"_37":332,"_39":40,"_41":333,"_43":334,"_45":335,"_47":48},"-Kb2tjHP",{},[],"OOP to me means only messaging, local retention and protection and hiding of state-process, and extreme late-binding of all things. It can be done in Smalltalk and in LISP. There are possibly other systems in which this is possible, but I'm not aware of them.",{"_31":337,"_33":338},[],{"_35":36,"_37":339,"_39":40,"_41":340,"_43":341,"_45":342,"_47":48},"u40bNp_8",{},[],"Cheers,",{"_31":344,"_33":358},[345,352],{"_31":346,"_33":347},[],{"_35":36,"_37":348,"_39":40,"_41":349,"_43":350,"_45":351,"_47":48},"D43UBiEe",{},[],"Thank you,",{"_31":353,"_33":354},[],{"_35":36,"_37":355,"_39":40,"_41":356,"_43":357,"_45":79,"_47":48},"o5RhRNb9",{},[],{"_35":36,"_37":359,"_39":40,"_41":360,"_43":361,"_45":362,"_47":48},"bIPpoL4f",{"_99":190},[],"Alan",{"_31":364,"_33":365},[],{"_35":96,"_37":366,"_39":40,"_41":367,"_43":368,"_45":369,"_47":48},"ymqzZj0f",{},[],"E-Mail of 2003-07-26",{"_31":371,"_33":372},[],{"_35":96,"_37":373,"_39":40,"_41":374,"_43":375,"_45":376,"_47":48},"14CZXDR7",{},[],"Clarification of \"object-oriented\", 1 [E-Mail]",{"_31":378,"_33":379},[],{"_35":36,"_37":380,"_39":40,"_41":381,"_43":382,"_45":387,"_47":48},"RfLYOM8Y",{},[383],{"_35":126,"_64":384,"_67":385,"_41":386,"_47":48},[66,128,129,130],[132,133,134,135],{},"Date: Sat, 26 Jul 2003 13:47:59 -0800\nTo: Stefan Ram [removed for privacy]\nFrom: Alan Kay [removed for privacy]\nSubject: Re: Clarification of \"object-oriented\"",{"_31":389,"_33":390},[],{"_35":36,"_37":391,"_39":40,"_41":392,"_43":393,"_45":144,"_47":48},"xXo7uXRl",{},[],{"_31":395,"_33":396},[],{"_35":36,"_37":397,"_39":40,"_41":398,"_43":399,"_45":400,"_47":48},"Pc47Vmmn",{},[],"Content-Type: text/plain; charset=\"us-ascii\" ; format=\"flowed\"\nContent-Length: 3145\nLines: 68",{"_31":402,"_33":403},[],{"_35":36,"_37":404,"_39":40,"_41":405,"_43":406,"_45":407,"_47":48},"wI0WKNip",{},[],"One of the things I should have mentioned is that there were two main paths that were catalysed by Simula. The early one (just by accident) was the bio/net non-data-procedure route that I took. The other one, which came a little later as an object of study was abstract data types, and this got much more play.",{"_31":409,"_33":410},[],{"_35":36,"_37":411,"_39":40,"_41":412,"_43":413,"_45":414,"_47":48},"PfVMvS3A",{},[],"If we look at the whole history, we see that the proto-OOP stuff started with ADT, had a little fork towards what I called \"objects\" -- that led to Smalltalk, etc.,-- but after the little fork, the CS establishment pretty much did ADT and wanted to stick with the data-procedure paradigm. Historically, it's worth looking at the USAF Burroughs 220 file system (that I described in the Smalltalk history), the early work of Doug Ross at MIT (AED and earlier) in which he advocated embedding procedure pointers in data structures, Sketchpad (which had full polymorphism -- where e.g. the same offset in its data structure meant \"display\" and there would be a pointer to the appropriate routine for the type of object that structure represented, etc., and the Burroughs B5000, whose program reference tables were true \"big objects\" and contained pointers to both \"data\" and \"procedures\" but could often do the right thing if it was trying to go after data and found a procedure pointer. And the very first problems I solved with my early Utah stuff was the \"disappearing of data\" using only methods and objects. At the end of the 60s (I think) Bob Balzer wrote a pretty nifty paper called \"Dataless Programming\", and shortly thereafter John Reynolds wrote an equally nifty paper \"Gedanken\" (in 1970 I think) in which he showed that using the lamda expressions the right way would allow data to be abstracted by procedures.",{"_31":416,"_33":417},[],{"_35":36,"_37":418,"_39":40,"_41":419,"_43":420,"_45":421,"_47":48},"RDZWSTbA",{},[],"The people who liked objects as non-data were smaller in number, and included myself, Carl Hewitt, Dave Reed and a few others -- pretty much all of this group were from the ARPA community and were involved in one way or another with the design of ARPAnet->Internet in which the basic unit of computation was a whole computer. But just to show how stubbornly an idea can hang on, all through the seventies and eighties, there were many people who tried to get by with \"Remote Procedure Call\" instead of thinking about objects and messages. Sic transit gloria mundi.",{"_31":423,"_33":424},[],{"_35":36,"_37":425,"_39":40,"_41":426,"_43":427,"_45":342,"_47":48},"vly4KB-W",{},[],{"_31":429,"_33":430},[],{"_35":36,"_37":431,"_39":40,"_41":432,"_43":433,"_45":362,"_47":48},"YgAhZPH_",{},[],{"_31":435,"_33":493},[436,450,457,465,472,479,486],{"_31":437,"_33":445},[438],{"_31":439,"_33":440},[],{"_35":36,"_37":441,"_39":40,"_41":442,"_43":443,"_45":444,"_47":48},"yFN01YqR",{},[],"OOP to me means only messaging, local retention and protection and\nhiding of state-process, and extreme late-binding of all things.",{"_35":36,"_37":446,"_39":40,"_41":447,"_43":448,"_45":449,"_47":48},"TYR2AsuI",{"_99":190},[],"On Wed, Jul 23, 2003 at 09:33:31AM -0800, Alan Kay wrote:",{"_31":451,"_33":452},[],{"_35":36,"_37":453,"_39":40,"_41":454,"_43":455,"_45":456,"_47":48},"X2944rT6",{},[],"Hi Alan,",{"_31":458,"_33":459},[],{"_35":36,"_37":460,"_39":461,"_41":462,"_43":463,"_45":464,"_47":48},"B6QqQY0o","bafy2bzaceaa6w5qa3havsie2r3tqwemf55ctg4lfqbmf7luqbdrarr7elywcq",{},[],"I just want to say \"thank you\" for your explanations (including the parts not quoted above)!",{"_31":466,"_33":467},[],{"_35":36,"_37":468,"_39":461,"_41":469,"_43":470,"_45":471,"_47":48},"fDRRBC7U",{},[],"\"local retention\" is a new notion to me in the context of OOP, and I assume it refers to state-process and means that an object is in possession of its state-process, so that the state of an object is kept locally with the object and not elsewhere.",{"_31":473,"_33":474},[],{"_35":36,"_37":475,"_39":461,"_41":476,"_43":477,"_45":478,"_47":48},"k-JjNSAs",{},[],"I have published your reply on the web, but have removed the E-Mail addresses and similar header lines for privacy.",{"_31":480,"_33":481},[],{"_35":36,"_37":482,"_39":40,"_41":483,"_43":484,"_45":485,"_47":48},"r8bsW31I",{},[],"Thanks again,",{"_31":487,"_33":488},[],{"_35":36,"_37":489,"_39":40,"_41":490,"_43":491,"_45":492,"_47":48},"q0zQqJcE",{},[],"Stefan",{"_35":36,"_37":494,"_39":40,"_41":495,"_43":496,"_45":497,"_47":48},"H79lKjk0",{"_99":190},[],"At 10:05 PM +0200 7/26/03, Stefan Ram wrote:",{"_31":499,"_33":500},[],{"_35":96,"_37":501,"_39":40,"_41":502,"_43":503,"_45":504,"_47":48},"sb3c81aa",{},[],"Remarks",{"_31":506,"_33":507},[],{"_35":36,"_37":508,"_39":40,"_41":509,"_43":510,"_45":511,"_47":48},"sNrrWSjY",{},[],"A memorandum on dataless programming:",{"_31":513,"_33":514},[],{"_35":36,"_37":515,"_39":40,"_41":516,"_43":517,"_45":523,"_47":48},"Fwm0yYh9",{},[518],{"_35":63,"_64":519,"_67":520,"_41":522,"_47":523},[66],[521],59,{},"http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_memoranda/2007/RM5290.pdf",{"_31":525,"_33":533},[526],{"_31":527,"_33":528},[],{"_35":36,"_37":529,"_39":40,"_41":530,"_43":531,"_45":532,"_47":48},"2odQpQTj",{},[],"720702 objektorientierte Programmierung\n721677 Programmiersprache\n720866 Kurse (Orte und Zeiten)\n720873 Lehrgang Aktiv programmieren lernen mit Java\n720872 Lehrgang Aktiv programmieren lernen mit C++\n721701 Rechtschreibreform, Schulsprache\nASCII-Tabelle JavaScript",{"_35":96,"_37":534,"_39":40,"_41":535,"_43":536,"_45":537,"_47":48},"0xSrWkgu",{"_99":190},[],"Other Pages of this Site",{"_31":539,"_33":540},[],{"_35":96,"_37":541,"_39":40,"_41":542,"_43":543,"_45":544,"_47":48},"IWG_vkV9",{},[],"About this page",{"_31":546,"_33":547},[],{"_35":36,"_37":548,"_39":40,"_41":549,"_43":550,"_45":558,"_47":48},"A5AsCy5D",{},[551],{"_35":63,"_64":552,"_67":554,"_41":556,"_47":557},[553],70,[555],92,{},"mailto:ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de","Impressum | Form for messages to the publisher regarding this page | \"ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de\" (without the quotation marks) is the email-address of Stefan Ram. | Beginning at the start page often more information about the topics of this page can be found. (A link to the start page appears at the very top of this page.)",{"_31":560,"_33":561},[],{"_35":36,"_37":562,"_39":40,"_41":563,"_43":564,"_45":565,"_47":48},"DNZ7wQMS",{},[],"Copyright 2004 Stefan Ram, Berlin. All rights reserved. This page is a publication by Stefan Ram. Stefan Ram Berlin slrprd slrprd stefanramberlin spellched stefanram721691 stefan_ram:721691 slrprd, slrprdqxx, slrprddoc, slrprd721691, slrprddef721691, PbclevtugFgrsnaEnz","version","account","z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8","authors",[568,571],"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou","path","/alan-kay-ideas/real-objects","createTime","2026-03-29T10:28:38.489Z","updateTime","2026-03-29T10:31:27.394Z","metadata",{"_580":581},"name","Real Objects","detachedBlocks",{},"genesis","generationInfo",{"_584":40,"_587":588},"generation","1774780118535","visibility","PUBLIC","isLatest",{"_572":593,"_566":461,"_596":24,"_597":568,"_37":598,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5},[594,595],"alan-kay-ideas","real-objects","latest","uid","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/real-objects","blockRef","blockRange","hostname","scheme","siteHomeIcon","ipfs://bafkreicdnqkw2kf5tznxhj2xyhyjqfursxoqqwpo4n7c2itnlkqbxnpqqq","dehydratedState",{"_607":608,"_609":610},"mutations",[],"queries",[611,1008,1086,1296,1302,1318,1439,1450],{"_612":613,"_1003":1004,"_1006":1007},"state",{"_614":615,"_988":989,"_990":991,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},"data",{"_35":26,"_26":616,"_37":986},{"_28":617,"_566":461,"_567":568,"_569":982,"_572":573,"_574":575,"_576":577,"_578":983,"_582":984,"_584":40,"_585":985,"_589":590},[618,623,628,637,642,656,666,700,715,735,740,745,750,755,760,785,790,795,800,805,810,815,820,835,840,845,854,859,864,869,874,879,884,889,934,939,944,953,963,968,977],{"_31":619,"_33":620},[],{"_35":36,"_37":38,"_39":40,"_41":621,"_43":622,"_45":46,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":624,"_33":625},[],{"_35":36,"_37":52,"_39":40,"_41":626,"_43":627,"_45":55,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":629,"_33":630},[],{"_35":36,"_37":59,"_39":40,"_41":631,"_43":632,"_45":72,"_47":48},{},[633],{"_35":63,"_64":634,"_67":635,"_41":636,"_47":71},[66],[69],{},{"_31":638,"_33":639},[],{"_35":36,"_37":76,"_39":40,"_41":640,"_43":641,"_45":79,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":643,"_33":653},[644],{"_31":645,"_33":646},[],{"_35":36,"_37":85,"_39":40,"_41":647,"_43":648,"_45":94,"_47":48},{},[649],{"_35":63,"_64":650,"_67":651,"_41":652,"_47":71},[90],[92],{},{"_35":96,"_37":97,"_39":40,"_41":654,"_43":655,"_45":102,"_47":48},{"_99":100},[],{"_31":657,"_33":663},[658],{"_31":659,"_33":660},[],{"_35":36,"_37":108,"_39":40,"_41":661,"_43":662,"_45":111,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":96,"_37":113,"_39":40,"_41":664,"_43":665,"_45":116,"_47":48},{"_99":100},[],{"_31":667,"_33":697},[668,677,682,687,692],{"_31":669,"_33":670},[],{"_35":36,"_37":122,"_39":40,"_41":671,"_43":672,"_45":137,"_47":48},{},[673],{"_35":126,"_64":674,"_67":675,"_41":676,"_47":48},[66,128,129,130],[132,133,134,135],{},{"_31":678,"_33":679},[],{"_35":36,"_37":141,"_39":40,"_41":680,"_43":681,"_45":144,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":683,"_33":684},[],{"_35":36,"_37":148,"_39":40,"_41":685,"_43":686,"_45":151,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":688,"_33":689},[],{"_35":36,"_37":155,"_39":40,"_41":690,"_43":691,"_45":158,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":693,"_33":694},[],{"_35":36,"_37":162,"_39":40,"_41":695,"_43":696,"_45":165,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":96,"_37":167,"_39":40,"_41":698,"_43":699,"_45":170,"_47":48},{"_99":100},[],{"_31":701,"_33":712},[702,707],{"_31":703,"_33":704},[],{"_35":36,"_37":176,"_39":40,"_41":705,"_43":706,"_45":179,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":708,"_33":709},[],{"_35":36,"_37":183,"_39":40,"_41":710,"_43":711,"_45":186,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":36,"_37":188,"_39":40,"_41":713,"_43":714,"_45":192,"_47":48},{"_99":190},[],{"_31":716,"_33":732},[717,722,727],{"_31":718,"_33":719},[],{"_35":36,"_37":198,"_39":40,"_41":720,"_43":721,"_45":201,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":723,"_33":724},[],{"_35":36,"_37":205,"_39":40,"_41":725,"_43":726,"_45":208,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":728,"_33":729},[],{"_35":212,"_37":213,"_39":40,"_41":730,"_43":731,"_45":217,"_47":48},{"_215":48},[],{"_35":36,"_37":219,"_39":40,"_41":733,"_43":734,"_45":222,"_47":48},{"_99":190},[],{"_31":736,"_33":737},[],{"_35":36,"_37":226,"_39":40,"_41":738,"_43":739,"_45":229,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":741,"_33":742},[],{"_35":36,"_37":233,"_39":40,"_41":743,"_43":744,"_45":236,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":746,"_33":747},[],{"_35":36,"_37":240,"_39":40,"_41":748,"_43":749,"_45":243,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":751,"_33":752},[],{"_35":36,"_37":247,"_39":40,"_41":753,"_43":754,"_45":250,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":756,"_33":757},[],{"_35":36,"_37":254,"_39":40,"_41":758,"_43":759,"_45":257,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":761,"_33":782},[762,767,772,777],{"_31":763,"_33":764},[],{"_35":36,"_37":263,"_39":40,"_41":765,"_43":766,"_45":266,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":768,"_33":769},[],{"_35":36,"_37":270,"_39":40,"_41":770,"_43":771,"_45":273,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":773,"_33":774},[],{"_35":36,"_37":277,"_39":40,"_41":775,"_43":776,"_45":280,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":778,"_33":779},[],{"_35":36,"_37":284,"_39":40,"_41":780,"_43":781,"_45":287,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":36,"_37":289,"_39":40,"_41":783,"_43":784,"_45":293,"_47":48},{"_99":291},[],{"_31":786,"_33":787},[],{"_35":36,"_37":297,"_39":40,"_41":788,"_43":789,"_45":300,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":791,"_33":792},[],{"_35":36,"_37":304,"_39":40,"_41":793,"_43":794,"_45":307,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":796,"_33":797},[],{"_35":36,"_37":311,"_39":40,"_41":798,"_43":799,"_45":314,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":801,"_33":802},[],{"_35":212,"_37":318,"_39":40,"_41":803,"_43":804,"_45":321,"_47":48},{"_215":48},[],{"_31":806,"_33":807},[],{"_35":36,"_37":325,"_39":40,"_41":808,"_43":809,"_45":328,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":811,"_33":812},[],{"_35":36,"_37":332,"_39":40,"_41":813,"_43":814,"_45":335,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":816,"_33":817},[],{"_35":36,"_37":339,"_39":40,"_41":818,"_43":819,"_45":342,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":821,"_33":832},[822,827],{"_31":823,"_33":824},[],{"_35":36,"_37":348,"_39":40,"_41":825,"_43":826,"_45":351,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":828,"_33":829},[],{"_35":36,"_37":355,"_39":40,"_41":830,"_43":831,"_45":79,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":36,"_37":359,"_39":40,"_41":833,"_43":834,"_45":362,"_47":48},{"_99":190},[],{"_31":836,"_33":837},[],{"_35":96,"_37":366,"_39":40,"_41":838,"_43":839,"_45":369,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":841,"_33":842},[],{"_35":96,"_37":373,"_39":40,"_41":843,"_43":844,"_45":376,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":846,"_33":847},[],{"_35":36,"_37":380,"_39":40,"_41":848,"_43":849,"_45":387,"_47":48},{},[850],{"_35":126,"_64":851,"_67":852,"_41":853,"_47":48},[66,128,129,130],[132,133,134,135],{},{"_31":855,"_33":856},[],{"_35":36,"_37":391,"_39":40,"_41":857,"_43":858,"_45":144,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":860,"_33":861},[],{"_35":36,"_37":397,"_39":40,"_41":862,"_43":863,"_45":400,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":865,"_33":866},[],{"_35":36,"_37":404,"_39":40,"_41":867,"_43":868,"_45":407,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":870,"_33":871},[],{"_35":36,"_37":411,"_39":40,"_41":872,"_43":873,"_45":414,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":875,"_33":876},[],{"_35":36,"_37":418,"_39":40,"_41":877,"_43":878,"_45":421,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":880,"_33":881},[],{"_35":36,"_37":425,"_39":40,"_41":882,"_43":883,"_45":342,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":885,"_33":886},[],{"_35":36,"_37":431,"_39":40,"_41":887,"_43":888,"_45":362,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":890,"_33":931},[891,901,906,911,916,921,926],{"_31":892,"_33":898},[893],{"_31":894,"_33":895},[],{"_35":36,"_37":441,"_39":40,"_41":896,"_43":897,"_45":444,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":36,"_37":446,"_39":40,"_41":899,"_43":900,"_45":449,"_47":48},{"_99":190},[],{"_31":902,"_33":903},[],{"_35":36,"_37":453,"_39":40,"_41":904,"_43":905,"_45":456,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":907,"_33":908},[],{"_35":36,"_37":460,"_39":461,"_41":909,"_43":910,"_45":464,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":912,"_33":913},[],{"_35":36,"_37":468,"_39":461,"_41":914,"_43":915,"_45":471,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":917,"_33":918},[],{"_35":36,"_37":475,"_39":461,"_41":919,"_43":920,"_45":478,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":922,"_33":923},[],{"_35":36,"_37":482,"_39":40,"_41":924,"_43":925,"_45":485,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":927,"_33":928},[],{"_35":36,"_37":489,"_39":40,"_41":929,"_43":930,"_45":492,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":36,"_37":494,"_39":40,"_41":932,"_43":933,"_45":497,"_47":48},{"_99":190},[],{"_31":935,"_33":936},[],{"_35":96,"_37":501,"_39":40,"_41":937,"_43":938,"_45":504,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":940,"_33":941},[],{"_35":36,"_37":508,"_39":40,"_41":942,"_43":943,"_45":511,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":945,"_33":946},[],{"_35":36,"_37":515,"_39":40,"_41":947,"_43":948,"_45":523,"_47":48},{},[949],{"_35":63,"_64":950,"_67":951,"_41":952,"_47":523},[66],[521],{},{"_31":954,"_33":960},[955],{"_31":956,"_33":957},[],{"_35":36,"_37":529,"_39":40,"_41":958,"_43":959,"_45":532,"_47":48},{},[],{"_35":96,"_37":534,"_39":40,"_41":961,"_43":962,"_45":537,"_47":48},{"_99":190},[],{"_31":964,"_33":965},[],{"_35":96,"_37":541,"_39":40,"_41":966,"_43":967,"_45":544,"_47":48},{},[],{"_31":969,"_33":970},[],{"_35":36,"_37":548,"_39":40,"_41":971,"_43":972,"_45":558,"_47":48},{},[973],{"_35":63,"_64":974,"_67":975,"_41":976,"_47":557},[553],[555],{},{"_31":978,"_33":979},[],{"_35":36,"_37":562,"_39":40,"_41":980,"_43":981,"_45":565,"_47":48},{},[],[568,571],{"_580":581},{},{"_584":40,"_587":588},{"_37":598,"_597":568,"_572":987,"_566":461,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":24},[594,595],"dataUpdateCount",1,"dataUpdatedAt",1779281894535,"error","errorUpdateCount","errorUpdatedAt","fetchFailureCount","fetchFailureReason","fetchMeta","isInvalidated","status","success","fetchStatus","idle","queryKey",[1005,598,461,24],"ENTITY","queryHash","[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/real-objects\",\"bafy2bzaceaa6w5qa3havsie2r3tqwemf55ctg4lfqbmf7luqbdrarr7elywcq\",false]",{"_612":1009,"_1003":1084,"_1006":1085},{"_614":1010,"_988":989,"_990":1083,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},{"_35":26,"_26":1011,"_37":1080},{"_28":1012,"_566":1018,"_567":568,"_569":1040,"_572":48,"_574":1041,"_576":1042,"_578":1043,"_582":1048,"_584":1077,"_585":1078,"_589":590},[1013],{"_31":1014,"_33":1015},[],{"_35":1016,"_37":1017,"_39":1018,"_41":1019,"_43":1039,"_45":48,"_47":48},"Query","ErSUf3Wu","bafy2bzacecbgc4o6jbt3at27kmuynptvbsdhyvnzhljcnkn7jfo5dqhcii2lm",{"_1020":1021,"_1022":1023,"_1024":1025,"_1038":24},"columnCount",3,"style","List","query",{"_1026":1027,"_1032":1033},"includes",[1028],{"_1029":568,"_572":48,"_1030":1031},"space","mode","AllDescendants","sort",[1034],{"_1035":24,"_1036":1037},"reverse","term","UpdateTime","banner",[],[568,571],"1970-01-01T00:00:00Z","2026-05-04T20:19:35.367Z",{"_580":1044,"_1045":604,"_1046":1047},"Dream Machines","icon","siteUrl","https://dream-machines-2.hyper.media",{"_1049":1050},"navigation",{"_31":1051,"_33":1076},[1052,1058,1064,1070],{"_31":1053,"_33":1054},[],{"_35":63,"_37":1055,"_47":1056,"_45":1057},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas?v=bafy2bzacec5n6atwxibonw2ziygzz7tf6v4ijersv5p54ilozfckl4eqfq3f6&l","Alan Kay Ideas",{"_31":1059,"_33":1060},[],{"_35":63,"_37":1061,"_47":1062,"_45":1063},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/def","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/def?v=bafy2bzacebc6oqimb7exo5zrjbtrj7kezsdof7ukrs7efvaw5ps4yyjptncwi&l","def",{"_31":1065,"_33":1066},[],{"_35":63,"_37":1067,"_47":1068,"_45":1069},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/lamport-ideas","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/lamport-ideas?v=bafy2bzacea7qr4ctkjgys2zwkoheoqwpaei5kdyza2bqbhsmxo2zukwhk2lw2&l","Lamport Ideas",{"_31":1071,"_33":1072},[],{"_35":63,"_37":1073,"_47":1074,"_45":1075},"AyFf-GfpKXQDrdFWWRgS5","hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/ai?v=bafy2bzaceahcjbecmj6vaipa6wio25tmadzw7mpd4wj3eb636zkevu4srkfbm&l","AI",{"_35":100,"_37":1049},"bafyreicretvprcx75xerxzdp65qt65x4xcs6f5cxtdkeb4va6ftqgkijsi",{"_584":1077,"_587":1079},"1",{"_37":1081,"_597":568,"_572":1082,"_566":-5,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8",[],1779281894537,[1005,1081,-5,6],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8\",null,true]",{"_612":1087,"_1003":1292,"_1006":1295},{"_614":1088,"_988":989,"_990":1291,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},[1089,1124,1145,1173,1194,1220,1244,1270],{"_35":26,"_37":1090,"_572":1095,"_569":1096,"_574":1097,"_576":1102,"_1105":1106,"_584":1107,"_566":1094,"_1108":1109,"_1112":1113,"_585":1120,"_1122":-5,"_578":1123,"_589":590},{"_37":1091,"_597":568,"_572":1092,"_566":1094,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/ai",[1093],"ai","bafy2bzacedh665nakauc4h4kpisknk2hinuwv4dmllpt6thjbsqsfeeiejaoq",[1093],[571],{"_1098":1099,"_1100":1101},"seconds","1777135985","nanos",518000000,{"_1098":1103,"_1100":1104},"1778503382",481000000,"sortTime","2026-04-25T16:53:05.518Z","bafyreiebaytq2oufbmck2hvq3j3kul4y4qwp67jcbxfv5chgzxqlu5lagy","breadcrumbs",[1110],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},"isMissing","activitySummary",{"_1114":-5,"_1115":48,"_1116":66,"_1117":1118,"_1119":6},"latestCommentTime","latestCommentId","commentCount","latestChangeTime",{"_1098":1103,"_1100":1104},"isUnread",{"_584":1107,"_587":1121},"1777135985524","redirectInfo",{"_580":1075},{"_35":26,"_37":1125,"_572":1130,"_569":1131,"_574":1132,"_576":1135,"_1105":1136,"_584":1129,"_566":1129,"_1108":1137,"_1112":1139,"_585":1141,"_1122":-5,"_578":1143,"_589":590},{"_37":1126,"_597":568,"_572":1127,"_566":1129,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/the-daemon-as-a-protocol-execution-substrate",[1128],"the-daemon-as-a-protocol-execution-substrate","bafyreiepq6jx7dhe32zvccmsxqx2uk7dgyafxxdw5hxnot6xxb67etdsfi",[1128],[571],{"_1098":1133,"_1100":1134},"1778170439",27000000,{"_1098":1133,"_1100":1134},"2026-05-07T16:13:59.027Z",[1138],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":-5,"_1115":48,"_1116":66,"_1117":1140,"_1119":6},{"_1098":1133,"_1100":1134},{"_584":1129,"_587":1142},"1778170439045",{"_580":1144},"The Daemon as a Protocol Execution Substrate",{"_35":26,"_37":1146,"_572":1151,"_569":1152,"_574":1153,"_576":1156,"_1105":1159,"_584":1160,"_566":1150,"_1108":1161,"_1112":1163,"_585":1169,"_1122":-5,"_578":1171,"_589":590},{"_37":1147,"_597":568,"_572":1148,"_566":1150,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/joe-armstrong-ideas",[1149],"joe-armstrong-ideas","bafy2bzaced2rm7e3tgl35h35fz63koaslrvxfsixjxzoilh46stso3o6st4wk",[1149],[571],{"_1098":1154,"_1100":1155},"1777651274",925000000,{"_1098":1157,"_1100":1158},"1777921587",797000000,"2026-05-01T16:01:14.925Z","bafyreifzyq4uzjw33lu6323miyprg4u63nrlwllwftu6mrkyw2ilw34vji",[1162],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":1164,"_1115":1167,"_1116":989,"_1117":1168,"_1119":6},{"_1098":1165,"_1100":1166},"1777651301",513000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6GZZaQerqMwCM",{"_1098":1157,"_1100":1158},{"_584":1160,"_587":1170},"1777651274930",{"_580":1172},"Joe Armstrong Ideas",{"_35":26,"_37":1174,"_572":1179,"_569":1180,"_574":1181,"_576":1184,"_1105":1185,"_584":1178,"_566":1178,"_1108":1186,"_1112":1188,"_585":1190,"_1122":-5,"_578":1192,"_589":590},{"_37":1175,"_597":568,"_572":1176,"_566":1178,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/the-dream",[1177],"the-dream","bafyreiep7gerekk54odnln4qhpuub6gtyfz7ug2fz6uumrlllivqwvpapy",[1177],[571],{"_1098":1182,"_1100":1183},"1777141438",320000000,{"_1098":1182,"_1100":1183},"2026-04-25T18:23:58.320Z",[1187],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":-5,"_1115":48,"_1116":66,"_1117":1189,"_1119":24},{"_1098":1182,"_1100":1183},{"_584":1178,"_587":1191},"1777141438325",{"_580":1193},"The Dream",{"_35":26,"_37":1195,"_572":1198,"_569":1199,"_574":1200,"_576":1203,"_1105":1206,"_584":1207,"_566":1197,"_1108":1208,"_1112":1210,"_585":1217,"_1122":-5,"_578":1219,"_589":590},{"_37":1055,"_597":568,"_572":1196,"_566":1197,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},[594],"bafy2bzacedubn6z4ifbznm3c5cv7q7kpjvpdlstfjhwchrtla32k46va3genu",[594],[571,568],{"_1098":1201,"_1100":1202},"1774774039",950000000,{"_1098":1204,"_1100":1205},"1777140851",574000000,"2026-03-29T08:47:19.950Z","bafyreiazwd7kij6z27wx7erl4cw6ukjtqs5g5p5rjo33lxjxysynplq5yy",[1209],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":1211,"_1115":1214,"_1116":1215,"_1117":1216,"_1119":6},{"_1098":1212,"_1100":1213},"1776671190",674000000,"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou/z6GPnrDPaMQUWp",2,{"_1098":1204,"_1100":1205},{"_584":1207,"_587":1218},"1774774039976",{"_580":1057},{"_35":26,"_37":1221,"_572":1226,"_569":1227,"_574":1228,"_576":1231,"_1105":1234,"_584":1235,"_566":1225,"_1108":1236,"_1112":1238,"_585":1240,"_1122":-5,"_578":1242,"_589":590},{"_37":1222,"_597":568,"_572":1223,"_566":1225,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/naming-and-synchronization-in-a-decentralized-computer-system",[1224],"naming-and-synchronization-in-a-decentralized-computer-system","bafy2bzacealbj5lk2lqkhurhfanvgzkokvsy6zi7km4hz6n76qr63ttzvwxq4",[1224],[571],{"_1098":1229,"_1100":1230},"1776273276",125000000,{"_1098":1232,"_1100":1233},"1776276625",221000000,"2026-04-15T17:14:36.125Z","bafyreieasis5q573t6jqzodvzepi2cuxhcij3k72cxhdao6cgvwwgpgpny",[1237],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":-5,"_1115":48,"_1116":66,"_1117":1239,"_1119":6},{"_1098":1232,"_1100":1233},{"_584":1235,"_587":1241},"1776273276153",{"_580":1243},"Naming and Synchronization in a Decentralized Computer System",{"_35":26,"_37":1245,"_572":1249,"_569":1250,"_574":1251,"_576":1254,"_1105":1257,"_584":1258,"_566":1248,"_1108":1259,"_1112":1261,"_585":1267,"_1122":-5,"_578":1269,"_589":590},{"_37":1067,"_597":568,"_572":1246,"_566":1248,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},[1247],"lamport-ideas","bafy2bzacea7qr4ctkjgys2zwkoheoqwpaei5kdyza2bqbhsmxo2zukwhk2lw2",[1247],[571],{"_1098":1252,"_1100":1253},"1774860333",964000000,{"_1098":1255,"_1100":1256},"1774864986",577000000,"2026-03-30T08:45:33.964Z","bafyreifinpq34rckcqzbp6ove4rm7qo2ysxsvwknr7tge5xywhn7ks7z2y",[1260],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":1262,"_1115":1265,"_1116":989,"_1117":1266,"_1119":6},{"_1098":1263,"_1100":1264},"1777199564",751000000,"z6Mkm8Uq6nbJDcA5ZyQCAhocWcL6KFfJkC7fFe465ZsMa6tw/z6GV4NmofQ1eGB",{"_1098":1255,"_1100":1256},{"_584":1258,"_587":1268},"1774860334010",{"_580":1069},{"_35":26,"_37":1271,"_572":1274,"_569":1275,"_574":1276,"_576":1279,"_1105":1282,"_584":1283,"_566":1273,"_1108":1284,"_1112":1286,"_585":1288,"_1122":-5,"_578":1290,"_589":590},{"_37":1061,"_597":568,"_572":1272,"_566":1273,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5,"_596":6},[1063],"bafy2bzacebc6oqimb7exo5zrjbtrj7kezsdof7ukrs7efvaw5ps4yyjptncwi",[1063],[571],{"_1098":1277,"_1100":1278},"1774802895",474000000,{"_1098":1280,"_1100":1281},"1774802957",394000000,"2026-03-29T16:48:15.474Z","bafyreifgdoxc5x2fj32iyqww7ezt7cq5cqsy4ncsjlndbnvp76c6ctqptm",[1285],{"_580":1044,"_572":48,"_1111":24},{"_1114":-5,"_1115":48,"_1116":66,"_1117":1287,"_1119":24},{"_1098":1280,"_1100":1281},{"_584":1283,"_587":1289},"1774802895516",{"_580":1063},1779281894544,[1293,1081,1294],"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY","Children","[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8\",\"Children\"]",{"_612":1297,"_1003":1300,"_1006":1301},{"_614":1298,"_988":989,"_990":1299,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},[],1779281894550,[1293,598,1294],"[\"DOC_LIST_DIRECTORY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/real-objects\",\"Children\"]",{"_612":1303,"_1003":1315,"_1006":1317},{"_614":1304,"_988":989,"_990":1314,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},{"_1305":1215,"_1306":989,"_1307":1215,"_31":66,"_1308":1309,"_1310":1311},"citations","comments","changes","authorUids",[568,571],"blocks",{"_468":1312,"_418":1313},{"_1305":989,"_1306":66},{"_1305":989,"_1306":989},1779281894638,[1316,598],"DOCUMENT_INTERACTION_SUMMARY","[\"DOCUMENT_INTERACTION_SUMMARY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/real-objects\"]",{"_612":1319,"_1003":1437,"_1006":1438},{"_614":1320,"_988":989,"_990":1436,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},{"_35":26,"_26":1321,"_37":1434},{"_28":1322,"_566":1197,"_567":568,"_569":1428,"_572":1429,"_574":1206,"_576":1430,"_578":1431,"_582":1432,"_584":1207,"_585":1433,"_589":590},[1323,1334,1341,1349,1357,1365,1373,1381,1389,1397,1405,1413,1421],{"_31":1324,"_33":1325},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1327,"_39":1328,"_41":1329,"_43":1332,"_45":48,"_47":1333},"Embed","qQxqI2GpcX","bafy2bzaceadm6hk3ks4z2sslwauqxsa7wrcyc35lxcvcoiki4erewd5lbxcpg",{"_1330":1331},"view","Card",[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/data-and-procedures-together",{"_31":1335,"_33":1336},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1337,"_39":1338,"_41":1339,"_43":1340,"_45":48,"_47":598},"vuUnFBEji-","bafy2bzacebixicrmwhrdizn7bl36oqrwpxwhpyssgnzg62ev3xrr45oxaddgi",{"_1330":1331},[],{"_31":1342,"_33":1343},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1344,"_39":1345,"_41":1346,"_43":1347,"_45":48,"_47":1348},"uMemzrnQEp","bafy2bzacea3dqynfw2h2mqxmplj32nyoc67tifg7veebupq5i23kdbk4o4bia",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/what-is-oop-for-alan-kay",{"_31":1350,"_33":1351},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1352,"_39":1353,"_41":1354,"_43":1355,"_45":48,"_47":1356},"tMigsHHW5w","bafy2bzacedmj75buox6pkl5ucux5yfvl3voortthvuxzbmmms77nhxh3zxmvk",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-big-idea-is-messaging",{"_31":1358,"_33":1359},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1360,"_39":1361,"_41":1362,"_43":1363,"_45":48,"_47":1364},"NRbD_3XDsz","bafy2bzacebgdldbwivkoqguxupxiezsup3errilyf3o5xbqzxdosnu4fpdra4",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/master-and-instances-to-activities-and-processes",{"_31":1366,"_33":1367},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1368,"_39":1369,"_41":1370,"_43":1371,"_45":48,"_47":1372},"s_acVt1fPE","bafy2bzacea3yhwqxac5jd7rhjmeoedxy3y7kuamawy5zafx6ikw3mv3kzsyna",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/dynamic-meanings-not-static-meanings",{"_31":1374,"_33":1375},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1376,"_39":1377,"_41":1378,"_43":1379,"_45":48,"_47":1380},"Kif3H1fUMq","bafy2bzaceddyaqp7tkpaufbwnztkzcgklxixmlkmgeddqbe3m7szucqkdly3e",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/semantic-negotiation",{"_31":1382,"_33":1383},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1384,"_39":1385,"_41":1386,"_43":1387,"_45":48,"_47":1388},"WaNoPBvCtG","bafy2bzacecnm42frhou6a6gq4a6vfe7d522hr2deviaje3l4bexs4srozxkie",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/biological-information-processing",{"_31":1390,"_33":1391},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1392,"_39":1393,"_41":1394,"_43":1395,"_45":48,"_47":1396},"48ehdnBoFT","bafy2bzaced52kgxzzygklugfnanmrq2vykxn7knpz2ac4bf7cxcoi3eimykpo",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/the-art-of-the-metaobject-protocol",{"_31":1398,"_33":1399},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1400,"_39":1401,"_41":1402,"_43":1403,"_45":48,"_47":1404},"eux-4oxTVT","bafy2bzacec5n6atwxibonw2ziygzz7tf6v4ijersv5p54ilozfckl4eqfq3f6",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/ideas-on-systems",{"_31":1406,"_33":1407},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1408,"_39":1409,"_41":1410,"_43":1411,"_45":48,"_47":1412},"cAuBYxum0C","bafy2bzaceaczxcws2sdbhzuw4fpciiwtnmcoqiuzpaxvdw6w26yovkqtd2q3w",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/alan-kay-on-agents",{"_31":1414,"_33":1415},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1416,"_39":1417,"_41":1418,"_43":1419,"_45":48,"_47":1420},"yiyc2XMiwY","bafy2bzacedxqb5x3a42b7lyxv26mxuynaslud7zxgokdzepkzobowvne2jspi",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/distributed-objects-versus-rest",{"_31":1422,"_33":1423},[],{"_35":1326,"_37":1424,"_39":1197,"_41":1425,"_43":1426,"_45":48,"_47":1427},"mTb2LsA8_9",{"_1330":1331},[],"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas/constraint-programming",[568,571],"/alan-kay-ideas","2026-04-25T18:14:11.574Z",{"_580":1057},{},{"_584":1207,"_587":1218},{"_37":1055,"_597":568,"_572":1435,"_566":-5,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5},[594],1779281894547,[1005,1055,-5,24],"[\"ENTITY\",\"hm://z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8/alan-kay-ideas\",null,false]",{"_612":1440,"_1003":1447,"_1006":1449},{"_614":1441,"_988":989,"_990":1446,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},{"_35":567,"_37":1442,"_578":1444},{"_566":1018,"_597":568,"_37":1081,"_572":1443,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5},[],{"_580":1044,"_1045":604,"_1046":1047,"_1445":-5},"summary",1779281894641,[1448,568],"ACCOUNT","[\"ACCOUNT\",\"z6Mkg7Cizn2g6h9sheDdF6JuHpHY95XK9LUAe6urCieoimC8\"]",{"_612":1451,"_1003":1476,"_1006":1477},{"_614":1452,"_988":989,"_990":1475,"_992":-5,"_993":66,"_994":66,"_995":66,"_996":-5,"_997":-5,"_998":24,"_999":1000,"_1001":1002},{"_35":567,"_37":1453,"_578":1457},{"_566":1454,"_597":571,"_37":1455,"_572":1456,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5},"bafy2bzaceabhdpa5ank4kbtyway5mp5z7mklegnt2k7swoctyy3tykepblqas","hm://z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou",[],{"_580":1458,"_1045":1459,"_1460":1459,"_1461":1462,"_1046":1463,"_1464":48,"_1465":1466,"_1467":48,"_1468":24,"_1469":1470,"_1471":1472,"_1445":-5},"Gabo H Beaumont","ipfs://bafkreifg4zwc2bidz3zuddxbld6dzeq5xfmbfhrzgx4hpj5bkxqtw6mgku","thumbnail","cover","ipfs://bafybeiguwj7jll23xgh37usasgzapg7n5x2xfbzyat3jyrdthmwv2mufe4","https://gabo.es","layout","displayPublishTime","2025-01-21","seedExperimentalLogo","showActivity","contentWidth","L","theme",{"_1473":1474},"headerLayout","Center",1779281894645,[1448,571],"[\"ACCOUNT\",\"z6MkrbYsRzKb1VABdvhsDSAk6JK8fAszKsyHhcaZigYeWCou\"]","ssrContentHTML","

Dr. Alan Kay explains when "object-oriented" was first used and what it means.

[] (Meaning of "Object-Oriented Programming" According to Dr. Alan Kay (meaning of OOP objectoriented definition term notion meaning explanation what is)), document, page 721691

https://www.purl.org/stefan_ram/pub/doc_kay_oop_en (permalink) is the canonical URI of this page.

Stefan Ram

Dr. Alan Kay on the Meaning of “Object-Oriented Programming”

(To link to this page, please use the canonical URI "https://www.purl.org/stefan_ram/pub/doc_kay_oop_en" only, because any other URI is valid only temporarily.)

E-Mail of 2003-07-23

Dr. Alan Kay was so kind as to answer my questions about the term “object-oriented programming”.

Clarification of "object-oriented" [E-Mail]

Date: Wed, 23 Jul 2003 09:33:31 -0800\nTo: Stefan Ram [removed for privacy]\nFrom: Alan Kay [removed for privacy]\nSubject: Re: Clarification of "object-oriented"

[some header lines removed for privacy]

Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" ; format="flowed"\nContent-Length: 4965\nLines: 117

Hi Stefan --

Sorry for the delay but I was on vacation.

At 6:27 PM +0200 7/17/03, Stefan Ram wrote:

Dear Dr. Kay,
I would like to have some authoritative word on the term\n"object-oriented programming" for my tutorial page on the\nsubject. The only two sources I consider to be "authoritative"\nare the International Standards Organization, which defines\n"object-oriented" in "ISO/IEC 2382-15", and you, because,\nas they say, you have coined that term.

I'm pretty sure I did.

Unfortunately, it is difficult to find a web page or source\nwith your definition or description of that term. There are\nseveral reports about what you might have said in this regard\n(like "inheritance, polymorphism and encapsulation"), but\nthese are not first-hand sources. I am also aware that later\nyou put more emphasis on "messaging" - but I still would like\nto know about "object oriented".
For the records, my tutorial page, and further distribution\nand publication could you please explain:
When and where was the term "object-oriented" used first?  \n

At Utah sometime after Nov 66 when, influenced by Sketchpad, Simula,

the design for the ARPAnet, the Burroughs B5000, and my background in

Biology and Mathematics, I thought of an architecture for

programming. It was probably in 1967 when someone asked me what I was

doing, and I said: "It's object-oriented programming".

The original conception of it had the following parts.

I thought of objects being like biological cells and/or individual\ncomputers on a network, only able to communicate with messages (so\nmessaging came at the very beginning -- it took a while to see how to\ndo messaging in a programming language efficiently enough to be\nuseful).
I wanted to get rid of data. The B5000 almost did this via its\nalmost unbelievable HW architecture. I realized that the\ncell/whole-computer metaphor would get rid of data, and that "<-"\nwould be just another message token (it took me quite a while to\nthink this out because I really thought of all these symbols as names\nfor functions and procedures.
My math background made me realize that each object could have\nseveral algebras associated with it, and there could be families of\nthese, and that these would be very very useful. The term\n"polymorphism" was imposed much later (I think by Peter Wegner) and\nit isn't quite valid, since it really comes from the nomenclature of\nfunctions, and I wanted quite a bit more than functions. I made up a\nterm "genericity" for dealing with generic behaviors in a\nquasi-algebraic form.
I didn't like the way Simula I or Simula 67 did inheritance\n(though I thought Nygaard and Dahl were just tremendous thinkers and\ndesigners). So I decided to leave out inheritance as a built-in\nfeature until I understood it better.

My original experiments with this architecture were done using a model I adapted from van Wijngaarten's and Wirth's "Generalization of Algol" and Wirth's Euler. Both of these were rather LISP-like but with a more conventional readable syntax. I didn't understand the monster LISP idea of tangible metalanguage then, but got kind of close with ideas about extensible languages draw from various sources, including Irons' IMP.

The second phase of this was to finally understand LISP and then using this understanding to make much nicer and smaller and more powerful and more late bound understructures. Dave Fisher's thesis was done in "McCarthy" style and his ideas about extensible control structures were very helpful. Another big influence at this time was Carl Hewitt's PLANNER (which has never gotten the recognition it deserves, given how well and how earlier it was able to anticipate Prolog).

The original Smalltalk at Xerox PARC came out of the above. The subsequent Smalltalk's are complained about in the end of the History chapter: they backslid towards Simula and did not replace the extension mechanisms with safer ones that were anywhere near as useful.

What does "object-oriented [programming]" mean to you?  \n(No tutorial-like introduction is needed, just a short  \nexplanation [like "programming with inheritance,  \npolymorphism and encapsulation"] in terms of other concepts  \nfor a reader familiar with them, if possible. Also, it is  \nnot neccessary to explain "object", because I already have  \nsources with your explanation of "object" from  \n"Early History of Smalltalk".)

(I'm not against types, but I don't know of any type systems that aren't a complete pain, so I still like dynamic typing.)

OOP to me means only messaging, local retention and protection and hiding of state-process, and extreme late-binding of all things. It can be done in Smalltalk and in LISP. There are possibly other systems in which this is possible, but I'm not aware of them.

Cheers,

Alan

Thank you,
Stefan Ram

E-Mail of 2003-07-26

Clarification of "object-oriented", 1 [E-Mail]

Date: Sat, 26 Jul 2003 13:47:59 -0800\nTo: Stefan Ram [removed for privacy]\nFrom: Alan Kay [removed for privacy]\nSubject: Re: Clarification of "object-oriented"

[some header lines removed for privacy]

Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" ; format="flowed"\nContent-Length: 3145\nLines: 68

One of the things I should have mentioned is that there were two main paths that were catalysed by Simula. The early one (just by accident) was the bio/net non-data-procedure route that I took. The other one, which came a little later as an object of study was abstract data types, and this got much more play.

If we look at the whole history, we see that the proto-OOP stuff started with ADT, had a little fork towards what I called "objects" -- that led to Smalltalk, etc.,-- but after the little fork, the CS establishment pretty much did ADT and wanted to stick with the data-procedure paradigm. Historically, it's worth looking at the USAF Burroughs 220 file system (that I described in the Smalltalk history), the early work of Doug Ross at MIT (AED and earlier) in which he advocated embedding procedure pointers in data structures, Sketchpad (which had full polymorphism -- where e.g. the same offset in its data structure meant "display" and there would be a pointer to the appropriate routine for the type of object that structure represented, etc., and the Burroughs B5000, whose program reference tables were true "big objects" and contained pointers to both "data" and "procedures" but could often do the right thing if it was trying to go after data and found a procedure pointer. And the very first problems I solved with my early Utah stuff was the "disappearing of data" using only methods and objects. At the end of the 60s (I think) Bob Balzer wrote a pretty nifty paper called "Dataless Programming", and shortly thereafter John Reynolds wrote an equally nifty paper "Gedanken" (in 1970 I think) in which he showed that using the lamda expressions the right way would allow data to be abstracted by procedures.

The people who liked objects as non-data were smaller in number, and included myself, Carl Hewitt, Dave Reed and a few others -- pretty much all of this group were from the ARPA community and were involved in one way or another with the design of ARPAnet->Internet in which the basic unit of computation was a whole computer. But just to show how stubbornly an idea can hang on, all through the seventies and eighties, there were many people who tried to get by with "Remote Procedure Call" instead of thinking about objects and messages. Sic transit gloria mundi.

Cheers,

Alan

At 10:05 PM +0200 7/26/03, Stefan Ram wrote:

On Wed, Jul 23, 2003 at 09:33:31AM -0800, Alan Kay wrote:
OOP to me means only messaging, local retention and protection and\nhiding of state-process, and extreme late-binding of all things.
Hi Alan,
I just want to say "thank you" for your explanations (including the parts not quoted above)!
"local retention" is a new notion to me in the context of OOP, and I assume it refers to state-process and means that an object is in possession of its state-process, so that the state of an object is kept locally with the object and not elsewhere.
I have published your reply on the web, but have removed the E-Mail addresses and similar header lines for privacy.
Thanks again,
Stefan

Remarks

A memorandum on dataless programming:

http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_memoranda/2007/RM5290.pdf

Other Pages of this Site

720702 objektorientierte Programmierung\n721677 Programmiersprache\n720866 Kurse (Orte und Zeiten)\n720873 Lehrgang Aktiv programmieren lernen mit Java\n720872 Lehrgang Aktiv programmieren lernen mit C++\n721701 Rechtschreibreform, Schulsprache\nASCII-Tabelle JavaScript

About this page

Impressum | Form for messages to the publisher regarding this page | "ram@zedat.fu-berlin.de" (without the quotation marks) is the email-address of Stefan Ram. | Beginning at the start page often more information about the topics of this page can be found. (A link to the start page appears at the very top of this page.)

Copyright 2004 Stefan Ram, Berlin. All rights reserved. This page is a publication by Stefan Ram. Stefan Ram Berlin slrprd slrprd stefanramberlin spellched stefanram721691 stefan_ram:721691 slrprd, slrprdqxx, slrprddoc, slrprd721691, slrprddef721691, PbclevtugFgrsnaEnz

","enableWebSigning","https://lunaticoin.blog","origin","homeMetadata",{"_580":1485,"_1045":1486,"_1046":1481,"_1464":48,"_1467":48,"_1487":24,"_1468":24,"_1469":1470,"_1471":1488},"Lunaticoin","ipfs://bafkreicbleoxq7kuohibnqo67ukpj6pwhnddzzzvwijztydnoaj4zzspy4","showOutline",{"_1473":1474},"originHomeId",{"_597":1491,"_37":1492,"_572":1493,"_566":-5,"_599":-5,"_600":-5,"_601":-5,"_602":-5},"z6MkpHiG87oJnyMajxKyJcEwNRTbrHWjKSnmVxuuxq7bP3nb","hm://z6MkpHiG87oJnyMajxKyJcEwNRTbrHWjKSnmVxuuxq7bP3nb",[],"meta",{"_1496":1497,"_1629":1630},"values",{"_1498":1499,"_1501":1502,"_1503":1504,"_1505":1506,"_1508":1509,"_1510":1511,"_1512":1513,"_1515":1516,"_1517":1518,"_1519":1520,"_1521":1522,"_1523":1524,"_1525":1526,"_1527":1528,"_1529":1530,"_1531":1532,"_1533":1534,"_1535":1536,"_1537":1538,"_1539":1540,"_1541":1542,"_1543":1544,"_1545":1546,"_1547":1548,"_1549":1550,"_1551":1552,"_1553":1554,"_1555":1556,"_1557":1558,"_1559":1560,"_1561":1562,"_1563":1564,"_1565":1566,"_1567":1568,"_1569":1570,"_1571":1572,"_1573":1574,"_1575":1576,"_1577":1578,"_1579":1580,"_1581":1582,"_1583":1584,"_1585":1586,"_1587":1588,"_1589":1590,"_1591":1592,"_1593":1594,"_1595":1596,"_1597":1598,"_1599":1600,"_1601":1602,"_1603":1604,"_1605":1606,"_1607":1608,"_1609":1610,"_1611":1612,"_1613":1614,"_1615":1616,"_1617":1618,"_1619":1620,"_1621":1622,"_1623":1624,"_1625":1626,"_1627":1628},"document.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"bigint","dehydratedState.queries.0.state.data.document.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.1.state.data.document.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.1.queryKey.2",[1507],"undefined","dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.sortTime",[1514],"Date","dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.0.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.1.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.2.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.3.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.4.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.5.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestCommentTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.6.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.createTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.updateTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.sortTime",[1514],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestCommentTime",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.activitySummary.latestChangeTime.seconds",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.2.state.data.7.redirectInfo",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.5.state.data.document.generationInfo.generation",[1500],"dehydratedState.queries.5.queryKey.2",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.6.state.data.metadata.summary",[1507],"dehydratedState.queries.7.state.data.metadata.summary",[1507],"referentialEqualities",{"_1498":1631,"_1510":1632,"_1523":1633,"_1539":1634,"_1551":1635,"_1567":1636,"_1575":1637,"_1581":1638,"_1595":1639,"_1609":1640},[1501],[1517],[1525,1531],[1545],[1553,1559],[1573],[1621],[1587],[1601],[1615],"actionData","errors"]